FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Vanderbilt Faculty Senate Votes Overwhelmingly to Adopt Resolution Opposing
Trump Loyalty Oath, Following Closely on Heels of Anti-Compact March, Rally
NASHVILLE, TN – Wednesday, October 8, 2025 — The Vanderbilt Faculty Senate met in emergency session Wednesday evening to discuss President Donald Trump’s proposed “Compact for Excellence in Higher Education.”
The session was well-attended by members of the Faculty Assembly, with an estimated 150-200 non-Senate faculty present.
Senator Jonathan Gilligan introduced the following resolution:
WHEREAS the United States Secretary of Education has requested that Vanderbilt University enter into a “Compact for Academic Excellence in Higher Education”, and
WHEREAS the Compact contains provisions antithetical to the mission and traditions of the University, and
WHEREAS the Compact contains provisions which endanger the independence and integrity of the University, and
WHEREAS the Compact likely violates state and federal law, and infringes upon the constitutional rights of members of the University community, and
WHEREAS Vanderbilt University exemplifies American academic values of the highest standard, including universal right to free speech and the cultivation of academic freedom; therefore
BE IT RESOLVED that the Faculty Senate of Vanderbilt University firmly opposes this Compact as written and calls upon Chancellor Diermeier and the Board of Trust to also reject this Compact outright as well as any similar proposal compromising the mission, values, and independence of the University.
Brief comments followed, all in support of the resolution.
Under Robert’s Rules of Order, the next regularly scheduled opportunity to vote on the resolution would have been November 23rd, making the vote moot given the deadline to respond to the invitation.
Several senators pressed for options to expedite voting, leading to an initial vote to suspend the Rules of Order, which passed by a super-majority (33 for, 11 against).
Debate on the resolution then began.
Senator Gilligan explained the text was closely modeled on the resolution passed by the University of Virginia Faculty Senate, to help ensure unity and solidarity across institutions in opposing the compact.
Several suggestions for additional language followed. Though remaining open to persuasion based on the overall sentiment of the room, Senator Gilligan again cautioned against language changes, an opinion then echoed by senators concerned with starting down a path of addressing every problematic aspect of the compact, an exercise likely to result in an unwieldy and less impactful overall statement.
Faculty anticipate the Vanderbilt administration will be in favor of joining the compact; a concern was raised that passing an independent resolution that challenges the administration may result in dissolution of the Faculty Senate, which serves at the pleasure of the Chancellor and Board of Trust.
After several further comments addressing these concerns, the vote proceeded, open to all elected senators as well as the dean of each of Vanderbilt’s 12 schools, who serve ex officio.
The resolution was adopted by a vote of 30 for, 11 against, 1 abstention.
Earlier in the day, a large group of students and faculty marched across the Vanderbilt campus to rally outside the Kirkland Hall administrative building, where they delivered a petition in opposition to the compact, at the time of delivery signed by over 1,000 Vanderbilt community members.
For further information, Senator Gilligan is available for comment.
